Article 17
Every prisoner of war, when questioned on the subject, is bound to give only his surname, first names and rank, date of birth, and army, regimental, personal or serial number, or failing this, equivalent information.
Does this apply to enemy combatants? Article V of the Convention states that all the protections apply to any captured persons until determination of status by a competent tribunal. What does that mean? I think some folks believe that it permits for falling into some third category of person to whom neither the protections of the Geneva Conventions or the Constitution will apply. This is a misreading of the Geneva Conventions and the Constitution. Either the Constitutional guarantees will apply or the Geneva Conventions will apply. To wit, either the detainee is entitled to being Mirandized or he is entitled to stay silent, except for his/her identity.
I have disagreed with Glenn Greenwald on the question of preventive detention. But it is clear that The Joe Kleins of the world are basically demanding Bush administration policies regarding the War on Terror. As Glenn writes:
All of these attacks on the Obama administration really leave one wondering: what is it exactly that Bush and Cheney did wrong? Was it just the waterboarding (the official authorization for which was withdrawn several years before Bush left office and which, in any event, people like Richard Cohen and Michael Crowley still crave)? Everything else other than the "enhanced interrogation techniques" was good? What happened to all the profound talk about how they ruined our image in the world and violated our "core principles" and how we can simultaneously Stay Safe and adhere to our values -- which happened to be a central theme of Obama's successful presidential campaign? How can Democrats and media stars claim to find Bush and Cheney so distasteful as they simultaneously attack Obama for reversing their defining policies in a few isolated instances? In the areas of civil liberties and Terrorism, what exactly did Bush and Cheney do wrong?
People like Klein and Cohen are quite ignorant on the issues and writing from irrational fear. It seems pretty clear that they never really objected to the Bush Administration policies on the War on Terror. This is true for most of the Village.
Speaking for me only